Dokumentverifikation mit Temporaler Beschreibungslogik

The thesis proposes a new formal framework for checking the content of web documents along individual reading paths. It is vital for the readability of web documents that their content is consistent and coherent along the possible browsing paths through the document. Manually ensuring the coherence of content along the possibly huge number of different browsing paths in a web document is time-consuming and error-prone. Existing methods for document validation and verification are not sufficiently expressive and efficient. The innovative core idea of this thesis is to combine the temporal logic CTL and description logic ALC for the representation of consistency criteria. The resulting new temporal description logics ALCCTL can - in contrast to existing specification formalisms - compactly represent coherence criteria on documents. Verification of web documents is modelled as a model checking problem of ALCCTL. The decidability and polynomial complexity of the ALCCTL model checking problem is proven and a sound, complete, and optimal model checking algorithm is presented. Case studies on real and realistic web documents demonstrate the performance and adequacy of the proposed methods. Existing methods such as symbolic model checking or XML-based document validation are outperformed in both expressiveness and speed.Die Dissertation stellt ein neues formales Framework für die automatische Prüfung inhaltlich-struktureller Konsistenzkriterien an Web-Dokumente vor. Viele Informationen werden heute in Form von Web-Dokumenten zugänglich gemacht. Komplexe Dokumente wie Lerndokumente oder technische Dokumentationen müssen dabei vielfältige Qualitätskriterien erfüllen. Der Informationsgehalt des Dokuments muss aktuell, vollständig und in sich stimmig sein. Die Präsentationsstruktur muss unterschiedlichen Zielgruppen mit unterschiedlichen Informationsbedürfnissen genügen. Die Sicherstellung grundlegender Konsistenzeigenschaften von Dokumenten ist angesichts der Vielzahl der Anforderungen und Nutzungskontexte eines elektronischen Dokuments nicht trivial. In dieser Arbeit werden aus der Hard-/Softwareverifikation bekannte Model-Checking-Verfahren mit Methoden zur Repräsentation von Ontologien kombiniert, um sowohl die Struktur des Dokuments als auch inhaltliche Zusammenhänge bei der Prüfung von Konsistenzkriterien berücksichtigen zu können. Als Spezifikationssprache für Konsistenzkriterien wird die neue temporale Beschreibungslogik ALCCTL vorgeschlagen. Grundlegende Eigenschaften wie Entscheidbarkeit, Ausdruckskraft und Komplexität werden untersucht. Die Adäquatheit und Praxistauglichkeit des Ansatzes werden in Fallstudien mit eLearning-Dokumenten evaluiert. Die Ergebnisse übertreffen bekannte Ansätze wie symbolisches Model-Checking oder Methoden zur Validierung von XML-Dokumenten in Performanz, Ausdruckskraft hinsichtlich der prüfbaren Kriterien und Flexibilität hinsichtlich des Dokumenttyps und -formats

Integrated Model Checking of Static Structure and Dynamic Behavior using Temporal Description Logics

This paper presents a new notation for the formal representation of the static structure and dynamic behavior of software, based on description logics and temporal logics. The static structure as described by UML class diagrams is represented formally by description logics while the dynamic behavior is represented by linear temporal logic and state transition systems. We integrate these descriptions of static and dynamic aspects into a single formalism called LTLDL. LTLDL enables a concise and natural yet precise definition of the behavior of software w.r.t. UML class diagrams and state transition diagrams. We demonstrate our approach on the sake warehouse problem. Further, we describe how properties of finite LTLDL models can be analyzed based on bounded model checking and SMT (satisfiability modulo theory) solving. We implemented a restricted SMT solver for finite sets and relations. This SMT solver helped to reduce the model checking runtime significantly as compared to bounded model checking with existing tools

Checking Semantic Integrity Constraints on Integrated Web Documents

A conceptual framework for the specification and verification of constraints on the content and narrative structure of documents is proposed. As a specification formalism we define CTLDL which is a new version of the temporal logic CTL extended with description logic concepts. In contrast to existing solutions our approach allows for the integration of ontologies to achieve interoperability and abstraction from implementation aspects of documents. This makes it specifically suitable for the integration of heterogenous and distributed information resources in the semantic web

Verifying the consistency of web-based technical documentations

AbstractA new framework for document verification is presented which covers the entire process from document analysis through information extraction, document modeling, representation of background knowledge about the domain of discourse, user level and formal representation of consistency criteria, verification by model checking, counterexample generation, and error reporting. Emphasis is placed on employing background knowledge to reduce the complexity and to increase the quality of results in each step. A rule-based approach to information extraction supports the concise definition of extraction rules for document formats based on XML or HTML. The expressiveness of the existing extraction methods is exceeded by supporting rule specialization, integration of external tools, and access to background knowledge represented in ontologies. As a formal basis for representing consistency criteria, the new temporal description logic ALCCTL is proposed. In contrast to the existing formalisms, criteria related to the coherence of content along individual paths of reading can be represented and verified efficiently. The adequacy, performance, and effectiveness of the proposed framework is demonstrated on a case study in technical documentation